Legal requirements and ethical issues john parrott photography. Programs like adobe photoshop allow users to make changes to. Ethical digital imaging requires that the original uncompressed image file be stored on archival media e. Digital image manipulation is the manipulation of images. Societal and ethical issues of digitization springerlink.
The celebrity angle pushes the issue further into the spotlight. There are advertisements, illustrations for news stories, snapshots from social media, and on and on. Although crane uses computer photo editing software on his photographs, he is judicious in its applications, and has strict, selfimposed rules. Ethics are a set of rules that we invent that define what we think is good and bad. Digital image manipulation or editing with software that stops short of. Images may be manipulated for fun, aesthetic reasons, or to improve the appearance of a subject but not all image manipulation is innocuous as evidenced by the kerry fonda 2004 election photo controversy. Finally we will tackle the legal and ethical issues that have been raised by image manipulation and ways these can be addressed or overcome. Many people are under the impression that digital manipulation began with the invention of photoshop like imaging software. Ethical considerations for scientific image manipulation by. Feb 17, 2015 the contest rules state the content of an image must not be altered. However, digital image and manipulation go hand in hand under the descriptive words of digital enhancement, referring to improving the quality of the photograph through software such as adobe photoshop or photopaint. The same principle follows us throughout the rest of our lives, but as we grow it takes on far greater implications and applies to so many more situations than a simple schoolyard game of hideandseek, hopefully exhibiting itself in personal, academic, professional, economic.
In some photographic genres, such as fashion and product photography including photos of food, a high level of manipulation aimed at producing perfection has long been general practice. Only retouching that conforms to currentlyaccepted standards in the industry is allowed. Today, billions of images are captured and shared between people and the number of image recording devices is growing at a rapid, unstoppable rate. Savedoff and mitchell contend that the upsurge in occurrence of digital manipulations will do to show the conceptualisation of digital photography.
Maintaining a copy of the unaltered original image is the users only protection against accusations of misconduct. The editor of american photo, david schonauer wrote that in the digital age nearly any impossible pairing can be manufactured. Image manipulation software has affected the level of trust many viewers once had in the aphorism, the camera never lies. Mar 16, 2018 in this paper we discuss the social and ethical issues that arise as a result of digitization based on six dominant technologies. Digital images digital image ethics digital image software these can all be found on the printable materials page. Ethics, image manipulation, and perception digital media. Image editing software programs, such as adobe photoshop, allow for the digital manipulation of an image to highlight the areas of interest and diminish the. From time to time there are news stories expressing outrage about manipulated photographs in advertisements and, heaven forbid, enhanced photos in news stories. All parameters of the production and acquisition of this file, as well as any subsequent processing steps, must be documented and reported to ensure reproducibility. Groups argue that image manipulation contributes to eating disorders in both women and men and a general decline in selfworth. That is the phrase amato 2000 uses to sum up digital manipulation. The issue of whether or not retouching photographs is ethical is a subjective concept and one that should be addressed by each individual photographer. When the first digital camera was invented, little did the inventors know that it would later revolutionize the world of photography and media in general. In clarification, an author may, quite ethically, attempt to clean up an image in order for it to be more readable.
The same could be said for using software to get rid of red eye no. Image manipulation has been with us since the earliest days of photography. Ethical and unethical implication of digital manipulation. The truth is that digital manipulation can be dated back to the invention of photography. But the potential for ethical questions arises primarily from postshoot image manipulation. The argument that digital manipulation is unethical can be supported in many ways. There are many theories and beliefs regarding ethics of digital manipulation. The contest rules state the content of an image must not be altered. The onus of any ethical decisions about digital image manipulation lies with the photographer or editor, not the application, industry professionals say. The legal requirements and ethical issues related to digital images and different areas of the photographic community. The dictionary says ethics are a set of moral principles or values and that ethical means conforming to accepted professional standards of conduct. This pbs nova video describes new software which uses mathematical techniques to look for telltale signs of image manipulation such as cloned regions. Manipulation for the juries was not about there being too much photoshop.
My images do have documentary aspects however, so ethical considerations do come into play. Crane regards any alteration of an image that changes the meaning of a photograph as unethical, and sufficient grounds for dismissal from a news outlet. Four and six is a company that produces software to authenticate digital images, and identify techniques commonly used by digital forgers. Although well intended, the manipulation of digital objects does beg some ethical considerations. The ethics of photo manipulation center for digital. The ethical debate regarding photo manipulation is. Legal requirements and ethical issues to digital images. Apr 08, 2014 the advent of digital editing software allows for easy digital composting and manipulation, which distorts the notion of reality in photography.
The range of changes that photo editors can make varies from correcting background lighting to transforming a human models body type. This article provides insight into life before adobe photoshop in the pre digital era showing the development of techniques and how they are different today. One of the first problems was that the flash didnt synch with the. Legal and ethical issues executive summary the purpose of this report is to analyses the legal and ethical issues associated with the changes in digital image tech analogies. Dec 19, 2011 the ethics of digital manipulation was written by jerry lodriguss, in this he talks about how can we believe anything we see. The ethics of manipulating andor enhancing photography is fraught. It would be easy for a magazine editor to forbid photo manipulation. No matter your feelings on digital manipulation or your ethical stance, the above situation saddens me. Michele mcnally is the director of photography and an assistant managing editor at the new york times. But opposing views suggest that image manipulation is a necessity for the upkeep of our idyllic view of celebrity culture, or is a form of art. Manipulation of digital images should only be performed on a copy of the unprocessed image data file always keep the original data file safe and unchanged.
After learning about the ethics of manipulating digital imagery it has made me aware of what is acceptable and unacceptable of is allowed and what isnt. Maintaining a copy of the unaltered original image is the users only protection against accusations of. Debating the rules and ethics of digital photojournalism the new. Ethical standards concerning computers and digital photography are not new issues, having been around for a long while. Alteration and manipulation of images on photographs to achieve the desired appearance are as old as photography itself. The analytical process used was conducting research on the issues relating to image and ethical use of images through online academic resources, these sources. Ethical guidelines for the appropriate use and manipulation of scienti. It is important to notice that image manipulation was possible before digital solutions. This report provides information obtained through research and analysis of the issues relating to and ethical use of digital imagery and digital image manipulation. The same principle follows us throughout the rest of our lives, but as we grow it takes on far greater implications and applies to so many more situations than a simple schoolyard game of hideandseek, hopefully exhibiting itself in personal, academic, professional, economic, and all other. Dec 06, 2012 the legal requirements and ethical issues related to digital images and different areas of the photographic community. The ethics of photo manipulation luminous landscape. Ethical considerations for scientific image manipulation, presented by postdoc emily wickline, phd, on march 20, 2014, as part of the howto talk series by the hsls molecular biology.
Picture imperfect digital image manipulation ethics. Ethics of digital manipulation 1558 words research paper. Apr 16, 20 from the moment were old enough to play games with other children, were told that cheating is bad. Any processing of images that are to be compared should be identical, especially if they will be published as a group of images in a single figure. I n 2009 french mps proposed a law telegraph s e pt 2009 that would require health warnings on any advertising images that had been digitally manipulated. Approaches and considerations regarding image manipulation in. Ethical dilemmas in some photographic genres, such as fashion and product photography including photos of food, a high level of manipulation aimed at producing perfection has long been general practice. In its discussion of image manipulation, this article highlights common approaches to image manipulation that may already be present in many digital collections and it is aimed at starting a larger conversation about postprocessing standardization. The advertisement click image shows the transformation of a model using both makeup and digital computer manipulation. While this example of photo manipulation required skilled artists and a timeconsuming process of physically altering the image, current digital image editing tools, often packaged free with the purchase of a digital camera or scanner, make the process relatively easy even for children to accomplish and to achieve similar results. The unacceptable side of this is when say in fashion or journalism, to alter the meaning or distort the truth, for example when a model poses for a magazine.
A descriptive analysis of codes of ethics and ethical decisions of photo editors by stephen edwin coleman december 2007 photography gave the world a lifelike memory. Sep 14, 2012 one of the more noteworthy examples of digital photo manipulation was the time magazine cover portrait of o. Ethical guidelines for the appropriate use and manipulation of scientific digital images 2010 cromey, d. Jan 22, 2015 more than 90% of creative professionals have adobe photoshop software on their desktops, according to a fact sheet from adobe, the parent company of photoshop.
Manipulation of digital images should always be done on a copy of the unprocessed image data file. From the moment were old enough to play games with other children, were told that cheating is bad. This discussion is not only limited to digital manipulation, but also includes conventional darkroom methods. More than 90% of creative professionals have adobe photoshop software on their desktops, according to a fact sheet from adobe, the parent company of photoshop. International journal of electronic security and digital. Starting off by taking a step in the past to look at the cottingley fairies case. We are bombarded with images from television, computer screens, newspapers, and magazines. To complicate matters, members of the public are usually totally unaware of or uninterested in whether an image has been adjusted. The original raw data file is the standard to which the final image can and should be compared. The ethical debate regarding photo manipulation is not new. The issue of whether or not retouching photographs is ethical is a.
Photo manipulation can give your magazine a dramatic, creative, and provocative visual boost that can generate higher sales. The ethics of magazine photo manipulation in the media. This discussion is not only limited to digital manipulation, but also includes. However, controversy can often result, which can inflict longterm damage if readers feel duped. Ethical guidelines for the appropriate use and manipulation of scientific digital images scientific digital images are data that can be compromised by inappropriate manipulations.
This report will pay particular attention to image and how this impacts the use of images within a digital environment and digital image manipulation in relation. People accept these images because thats what theyre accustomed to, and only the most naive believe them to be real. Thats why its tempting to change photographs to maximize their ability to grab eyeballs. However, this has largely failed to have happened due principally to differentiating between the printed or published digital or analogue photograph creating difficulty in identifying and developing a set of. The capability to manipulate, or even to dramatically alter a digital image with electron darkroom software, is a major ethical and legal concern because these images can play an essential role in. Digital image manipulation or editing with software that stops short of manipulation has become a routine practice in photography.
Editing the brightness and contract of an image or burning and dodging would be considered acceptable in majority of cases. It is my very strong belief that all digital manipulations that involve adding or subtracting components from an image, and all wildlife photographs of creatures that were not wild, free, and unrestrained must be honestly labeled by. This new digital imaging practice should pose a whole range of ethical considerations relating to the manipulation of photographs. General basic microscope alignment light microscopy tips formaldehyde fixatives light microscope vendors for southern arizona. It is especially well suited for journalism, but serves other areas exceptionally well also. Manipulation of digital images should only be performed on a copy of the unprocessed image data. Editing software colour management printers photo paper see all. Aug 22, 20 these professionals are the ones who can decide where to draw the line. What is new is the way of processing the digital images where they can be modified, enhanced, or even made to lie. Ethics of digital image manipulation unilag journal of.
These professionals are the ones who can decide where to draw the line. The ethics of digital manipulation was written by jerry lodriguss, in this he talks about how can we believe anything we see. Ijesdf aims to establish dialogue in an ideal and unique setting for researchers and practitioners to have a knowledge resource, report and publish scholarly articles and engage in debate on various securityrelated issues, new developments and latest proven methodologies in the field of electronic security and digital forensics. With software such as photoshop and adobe, it is easy to manipulate or alter a photograph in order to fit the desired appearance ball and kalmbach 27. I think in some aspect digital editing is good to hide the graphic detail of what is shown however it shouldnt change the truth. The ethics of digital manipulation astrophotography. We highlight the many developments in the digitizing society that appear to be at odds with six recurring themes revealing from our analysis of. Jul 18, 2019 photo manipulation can give your magazine a dramatic, creative, and provocative visual boost that can generate higher sales. Is editing a photo to convince viewers of something false an acceptable practice. Readers will accept fixing flaws, such as correcting colors or lighting. It allows just about anyone with a scanner or digital camera, basic software, and a little training to manipulate photographs, video and audio tapemaking the imagined, real.
Because no deception is involved, this creative technique will not raise ethical concerns. Debating the rules and ethics of digital photojournalism. One of the more noteworthy examples of digital photo manipulation was the time magazine cover portrait of o. The advent of digital editing software allows for easy digital composting and manipulation, which distorts the notion of reality in photography. It can be used to create false situations, to make people look better or fit an image, to improve the quality, to amuse or entertain. Digital images that will be compared to one another should be acquired under identical conditions, and any postacquisition image processing should also be identical. The jury is the ultimate arbiter of these standards. Ethical issues in digital manipulation lying with pixels sums up the issues involved with regard to digital manipulation. He removed trees with digital editing software from the image, said. In this paper we discuss the social and ethical issues that arise as a result of digitization based on six dominant technologies. But as soon as the redeye is removed from someones photo, the image is altered. Image manipulation in research articles enago academy.
696 1233 869 370 1160 1248 1112 69 649 1035 29 545 1322 1509 27 1435 59 1510 483 96 1187 292 963 1410 1384 1684 786 783 1631 1122 207 201 764 664 102 768 1417 1007